Class in Convict Society
Gary L. Sturgess
11/15/20269 min read


There’s never been any question that in First Fleet society, the convicts were socially inferior to the officers and gentlemen (and the one lady). They did not socialise together in public. Disrespectful remarks were (usually) punished. And while there are no known examples in the available sources, the convicts would have been obliged to doff their hats or nod their heads when they encountered their social betters in the street.
The distinction was one of class, not legal status. Convicts could speak offensively to private marines as long as they were not on guard duty, and they would be punished for insolence to convict overseers (that is, convicts supervising other prisoners) while the latter were performing their duties.
But there is also evidence of class distinctions amongst the convicts themselves – middle class convicts, trusted overseers and tradesmen, women who were in a relationship with one of the officers or gentlemen – these men and women kept themselves apart from ‘the common herd’.
Setting Oneself Apart
Language was one of the most obvious ways in which social status was signalled. Watkin Tench, a marine officer, explained:
'A leading distinction, which marked the convicts on their outset in the colony, was an use of what is called the flash, or kiddy language. In some of our early courts of justice, an interpreter was frequently necessary to translate the deposition of the witness, and the defence of the prisoner. . .'
Tench also observed that abandonment of cant was an important indicator that a man or woman was changing their ways:
'I have ever been of opinion, that an abolition of this unnatural jargon would open the path to reformation. . . I recollect hardly one instance of a return to honest pursuits, and habits of industry, where this miserable perversion of our noblest and peculiar facility was not previously conquered.'
Like Eliza Doolittle in ‘Pygmalion’, convicts were obliged to transform their speech if they were to be accepted into polite society, even polite convict society. In giving character evidence on behalf of Henry Abrams, a First Fleet convict overseer, John Shea (a marine captain) said that ‘he never made use of improper Language’. While Shea was probably referring to uncouth rather than flash language, his point was the same.
Physical appearance also mattered, and while few of the convicts would have owned clothing as fine as that of the officers and gentlemen, Shea noted that Abrams was ‘always very clean’.
Manners. Based on the conventions of the day, good manners would have been another way in which upwardly mobile convicts would have signalled respectability (although there are no known examples in the First Fleet sources).
Behaviour. The ‘better class of convicts’ also distinguished themselves through their conduct – ‘attention to their labour, and obedience to the orders they received’, behaving ‘remarkably well’, ‘unremitting in his diligence care and attention to the discharge of the trust reposed in him’.
Reputation
Over time, these qualities contributed to a reputation or ‘character’ that could be attested to by the gentlemen who knew them well. This is what happened when Henry Abrams was tried for speaking disrespectfully about two marine officers – the court accepted the character evidence of Shea and three other gentlemen over eyewitness accounts of the event.
Herbert Keeling, a middle-class convict who was close to Major Robert Ross (the Lieutenant Governor and the officer commanding the marines), told a private marine on October 1789 that he could produce 20 convicts whose word would be accepted by the Lieutenant Governor before the oaths of many marines.
Many of these men and women had started rehabilitating their reputation on the outward voyage. There are numerous examples of this, of which the following is a selection:
Watkin Tench said of Joshua Peck in a July 1788 trial for stealing from the hospital, that he had never heard of him acting dishonestly, ‘who he had an opportunity to know much of & had a good opinion of him’. [2]
Ross wrote of Keeling in November that year: ‘I first knew him on B'd the Scarboro’ Transport, where his conduct and behaviour was exemplary and meritorious. . .’
Around the same time, Captain Shea told the magistrates that: ‘. . . on the whole of the Passage from England [Abrams] behaved remarkably well & did receive Indulgence on that account. . .’
For some, the process of rebuilding their character had begun even earlier, in the hulks or the prisons. Shea noted that Henry Abrams came on board from the hulks wearing only a single iron, ‘the only one with that Mark of Good Behaviour’. The hulks contractor, Duncan Campbell, singled out John Irvine as a ‘clever fellow’ with some medical training.
A more economical way of establishing a reputation among strangers was to bring letters of recommendation written by respectable people at home. Tench noted that several of the First Fleet convicts arrived with such letters, and once the benefits of these testimonials were understood, forgeries appeared. They were immediately obvious as such, he wrote:
'One of them addressed to the governor [Arthur Phillip], with the name of Baron Hotham, affixed to it, began "Honoured Sir!"’
One convict who probably arrived with a letter of recommendation was Elizabeth Needham, whose father had been coachmen to Lady Charlotte Finch, governess to the royal family. Lady Charlotte was liberal-minded, and as a young girl, Elizabeth seems to have socialised with her children. Her eldest son, George Finch, was the Earl of Winchelsea when Elizabeth was convicted of shoplifting in 1786 and made representations to the government on her behalf. While he was unsuccessful in securing a pardon, it is likely that he supplied her with a letter of recommendation.
Mary Talbot, an escapee from the Lady Juliana (1789) who was retaken and sent out on the Mary Ann (1791), wrote to a gentleman in England on the outward voyage:
'If you will send to me, Sir, directed to be left for me at Governor Phillip's, New South Wales, and say anything in behalf of my character, it will serve me much; and if you can write immediately, the letter will be there before me. . . because your recommendation, in the most trifling degree, will do me great service on my arrival.' [3]
Socialising with their Equals
These men and women generally held themselves aloof from ‘the lowest class of these people’. As the Governor’s official secretary, David Collins, observed:
'. . . there were convicts of both sexes who were never known to associate with the common herd, and whose conduct was marked by attention to their labour, and obedience to the orders they received.'
Captain Shea testified that on the outward voyage, Henry Abrams ‘held himself distinct from the convicts’.
In October 1789, Herbert Keeling, who had recently been appointed as the principal of the convict nightwatch, informed a private marine named Arthur Dougherty that his wife was supplying spirits to one of the convict women. Among other things, he warned Dougherty that ‘by associating with the Convicts, [his wife] would bring herself to be as bad as them’. Merely to associate with the lower class of convicts was to jeopardise one’s reputation, and by implication, Keeling wasn’t associating with them either.
Given that they were forbidden to socialise with the officers and gentlemen, and (for the most part) the small number of free settlers who made up the public service of the colony, it is unsurprising that men and women of this layer of convict society attended one another’s dinner parties and served as witnesses to each other’s wills and contracts.
Middle Class Convicts
A number of the First Fleet convicts came from a middle-class background or had been in service in one of England’s great houses, and they brought with them speech and manners which enabled them to be at ease in polite society. Based on the victualling list for the First Fleet, which provides us with insight into the convicts’ messing arrangements on the outward voyage, these men and women were assigned to messes with others of their own kind, possibly because they had paid for the privilege. [4]
The following are three examples of middle-class convicts in the colony:
John Irvine – A young man ‘bred a surgeon’ but not formally qualified, Irvine had been transported for stealing a silver cup from a widow at Grantham in Lincolnshire. On the outward voyage, he served as the medical practitioner on the Prince of Wales; in the colony, he was assigned to the surgeon-general, John White, and while described as an assistant at the hospital, he was also used by White to manage his personal affairs.
Irvine would have dressed as a gentleman and most certainly would not have used flash language, but his social standing in the colony was ambiguous until February 1790, when he was given a free pardon (the first convict to benefit from Governor Phillip’s exercise of the royal prerogative of mercy).
Tench wrote that this pardon was ‘in consequence of [his] unremitted good behaviour and meritorious conduct’ and resulted in him being ‘restored to all those rights and privileges, which had been suspended in consequence of the sentence of the law’. [5] This would have included the right to associate freely with the officers and gentlemen.
Elizabeth Needham – It was widely understood in the colony that Needham enjoyed the Earl of Winchelsea’s patronage. Shortly after the arrival of the Second Fleet in June 1790, she did needlework for Elizabeth Macarthur, which suggests that it was acceptable to socialise with her to that extent, at least. In later years, Mrs Macarthur referred to her as ‘the foster-sister of the present Earl of Winchelsea, by whom she is still patronised’. [6]
Herbert Keeling had grown up in a respectable quarter of London’s West End and had served as a midshipman, a young gentleman’s rank, on naval vessels. Ross described him as ’a man of Education and considerable abilities’, and ‘a sincere convert to reformation of manners’, seeking a free pardon for him in 1789 based on the assistance he had provided him as Lieutenant Governor.
Convict Overseers
No thought had been given to sending civilian overseers out with the First Fleet to superintend the convict camps and work gangs, and Phillip, Collins and Ross selected people from amongst the prisoners who had trade qualifications or had manifest leadership skills and a sense of responsibility on the outward voyage.
These men were the elite of convict society. They had a privileged relationship with those responsible for governing the colony, evidenced by the rapport between Ross and Keeling. Huts were built for them as a matter of priority, and when at the swearing-in ceremony on the 7th of February 1787, the Governor encouraged the convicts to marry, a significant number of the overseers responded immediately.
As noted above, these men and the women kept themselves aloof from the main body of the convicts, socialising with one another instead.
The Gentlemen’s Companions
The other category of convicts who occupied an ambiguous social status and seem to have socialised together, were the women who cohabited with officers and gentlemen.
A number of these women were impressive figures who would distinguish themselves in later years, long after the gentlemen had gone home – which is presumably why the gentlemen singled them out in the first place. The gentlemen made financial provision for these women and their children before they left the colony, they generally adored the children, and they took them home or sent them back to England to be educated, including, in some cases, the girls.
Everyone knew what was going on, but it was overlooked as long as everyone maintained ‘a decent exterior’. When Mary Hughes gave evidence in a court martial in November 1789, she described herself as living with James Meredith, one of the marine captains. The transcript was changed to read ‘lives at Captain Meredith’s’. [7]
It would have been completely unacceptable for any of the gentlemen to promenade around the settlement with one of these women on his arm or to bring one of them to dinner. When their children were baptised, we know that fellow officers attended and served as witnesses and godfathers, and, given that the mothers would not have been excluded from the ceremony, these must have been socially awkward occasions.
We know even less about the relationships between these women and their fellow convicts, but we can assume that they were also difficult. The women certainly associated with one another, two of them sharing a hut at one time, and others socialising together and remaining lifelong friends.
Conclusion
There is overwhelming evidence from a variety of First Fleet sources that convict society was layered, with middle-class convicts and those who had been elevated through appointment as overseers, taking care to distinguish themselves from ‘the common herd’.
It is more difficult to know how such this strange little society worked, and while we can reconstruct some of its aspects, there is a great deal we still do not understand.
________________________
As usual, this Catspaw is not fully referenced. The author will provide references for particular passages upon request.
Unless otherwise identified, the sources for the quotes in this Catspaw are from:
David Collins, An Account of the English Colony in New South Wales, London: Cadell and Davies, 1798, p. 48.
Watkin Tench, A Complete Account of the Settlement at Port Jackson, London: Nicol and Sewell, 1793, pp. 207-208.
R v Abrams, Judge Advocate’s Bench of Magistrates, 1 November 1788, NSW State Archives, SZ765.
Robert Ross to Evan Nepean, 16 November 1788, UK National Archives (hereafter TNA) CO201/3/191-192a.
R v Keeling, Judge Advocate’s Bench of Magistrates, 13 October 1789, op cit.
_____
[1] AI rendering of Juan Ravenet, ‘Convictos en la Nueva Olanda [Convicts in New Holland]’, wash drawing. 19.5 x 12.5 cm, in Juan Ravenet & Felipe Bauza, ‘Drawings made on the Spanish Scientific Expedition to Australia and the Pacific in the ships Descubierta and Atrevida under the command of Alessandro Malaspina, 1789-94’, State Library of NSW, SAFE/DGD 2. The woman's hat has been removed from the original, because convict women did not generally wear men's hats, and because there is another drawing by Ravenet which shows an island woman wearing a similar hat, suggesting that aspect this was staged.
[2] R v Chadwick, Peck and Small, Judge Advocate’s Bench of Magistrates, 17 July 1788, op. cit.
[3]The Times, 18 October 1791
[4] See newsletter, Convict Messes on the First Fleet.
[5] Watkin Tench, A Complete Account of the Settlement, op. cit., p. 44.
[6] Elizabeth Macarthur to her son John Macarthur, 7 June 1824, ‘Elizabeth Macarthur Journal and Correspondence, 1789-1840’, Macarthur Family Papers, Volume 10, State Library of NSW, SAFE/A2906.
[7] Battalion Court Martial of Peter Dargin, 4-7 & 9 November 1789. TNA ADM1/5491.
AI Rendering of Jules Ravenet, 'Convicts in New Holland' [1]
Contact us
Botany Baymen acknowledges the traditional custodians of country throughout Australia and respects their connection to land, water and community.
© Botany Baymen 2024-2026. All rights reserved.
You may download, display, print and reproduce this content for your personal or non-commercial use but only in an unaltered form and with the copyright acknowledged.
Privacy Policy
Subscribe to our latest updates
Be the first in the know. We promise no spam.

